Let’s Talk DIY vs. Buy (And When to Stop Lying to Yourself)
There’s something magical about making something with your own hands. That Pinterest-worthy wreath? The birthday banner you saw on Etsy? The storage bench from TikTok?
But also… sometimes you just want the thing — no glue gun, no last-minute Michaels run, no tears.
If you’ve ever stood in an aisle wondering, “Could I just make this?”—this post is for you. Let’s break down when to DIY and when to just click “Add to Cart” and call it a day.
DIY Wins: When Making It Yourself Saves You Money
1. Home Decor That’s Trendy but Pricey
Trendy home decor pieces are often marked up because they follow what’s hot right now—boho vases, abstract wall art, or dried floral wreaths. Buying these can easily cost $40–$100 each. DIYing your own with dollar-store frames, faux flowers, and leftover paint can cost under $20. Plus, it allows you to customize to your exact style and color scheme. It’s especially worth it for renters or seasonal decorators who want to refresh their space without committing.
2. Party Decorations
Party stores charge a premium for decorations you’ll use for a few hours. Balloon garlands, banners, and treat table props add up fast. Making your own not only saves money but also adds a personal touch. Use cardstock, ribbon, twine, and a free online template to create something that looks amazing in photos. If you’re hosting on a budget or throwing multiple parties a year, DIY wins every time.
3. Natural Cleaning Products or Body Scrubs
Store-bought eco-friendly cleaners and scrubs are expensive, but making your own is fast and cheap. Basic ingredients like baking soda, vinegar, essential oils, and sugar can be used in tons of ways. You can make a lemon sugar scrub or a lavender room spray for less than $2 per batch. Bonus: No weird ingredients, and it feels like a mini spa project.
4. Gift Baskets or Personalized Presents
Pre-made gift baskets can be wildly overpriced, often full of filler. Creating your own with thoughtful items like snacks, socks, candles, or mini self-care items shows you put in the effort—and you can control the budget. A custom gift feels more personal and can be tailored to the recipient’s tastes without spending a fortune.
Buy It: When It’s Not Worth Your Sanity
5. Complex Furniture or Heavy-Duty Storage
DIY furniture is great in theory but usually requires tools, precision, and time. If you’re not experienced or you lack the space, it can lead to crooked builds and a lot of frustration. Buying ready-made shelves, cube organizers, or storage benches ensures they’re safe, sturdy, and functional without the headache.
6. Clothing (That Requires Sewing)
Unless you love sewing or already have a machine, most clothing projects are more expensive than buying similar ready-made items. Patterns, fabric, and tools add up quickly. Stick to easy DIYs like no-sew t-shirt bags, cut-off shorts, or iron-on designs—and leave the fitted blazers to the pros.
7. Anything That Requires Specialized Tools You Don’t Own
If a project requires a saw, soldering tool, or any equipment you’ll never use again, it’s probably not worth the investment. It might cost more to DIY once you factor in tool rental or purchase. In these cases, buying pre-made is faster and usually cheaper in the long run.
It Depends: When You Can Go Either Way
8. Wall Shelves
You can build floating shelves if you want custom sizes or finishes, especially with a few basic tools. But if you’re in a rush or not confident using power tools, buying shelves is the safer choice. Pre-made options are often affordable and ready to hang.
9. Holiday Decor
Seasonal projects are fun, especially if you enjoy crafting. DIYing garlands, ornaments, or table settings adds a handmade charm. But if you’re low on time, buying holiday decor helps you skip the mess. Consider a mix: DIY one or two standout pieces and buy the rest.
10. Organizers & Labels
If you love your Cricut, label-making can be oddly therapeutic. But for most people, it’s faster to buy ready-made organizers and slap on a label with a marker. DIY is great for personalized systems, but store-bought bins can be a major time saver.
The Real Question: Do You Want to DIY or Just Feel Like You Should?
Sometimes we romanticize the idea of doing it ourselves. It feels thrifty. Empowering. Creative. But if you’re already exhausted, hate messes, or know deep down you’ll never finish it? It’s okay to just buy the thing.
DIY should make you feel good. Not guilty. Choose what makes your life easier and brings you joy.
A Quick Checklist: Should You DIY or Buy?
Ask yourself:
- Do I already have the materials?
- Will this actually save me money?
- Will I enjoy doing it?
- Do I have the time/space to finish it?
- Will I reuse the tools or supplies again?
If you answered “yes” to at least 3—DIY it.
If not? Treat yourself. Add to cart. No shame.
Final Thoughts: You’re Not a Failure for Buying It
You don’t need to prove your worth by hot gluing a seasonal wreath at 10 PM. Sometimes DIY is magical. Other times, it’s just more stress.
Make things when it brings you joy. Buy things when you need a break. That’s the balance.
